And the answer is: of course that's what happened.
Because, as you'll see from these pictures, our formulas are too remarkably similar for there to be any other explination. So I've decided to post pics of my own, just to set the record straight.
That's Jesse Custer (A.K.A Preacher), girlfriend Tulip, and vampire pal Cassidy, from left to right. But let's look at pictures of each, since I bothered to take them in the first place.
Bob and I used the same starting point for this guy: the Spirit's chest, white legs, and a collar (though Bob chose an all-white collar, while I used a black one with a little white paint. Artist's interpretation, I guess). His head and hair come from VP Gaius Baltar, and while I still like the head, I have to admit that Bob's choice of hairpiece is better. But ultimately, mine is clearly superior, because... he's got a Bible! Yeah! What kinda Preacher doesn't have a bible?
Starbuck, and her hair's from the White Queen.
Cyclops head and Hydro-Man hair that worked nicely for him. We both used the same vest, though Bob did take the time there to paint his to be comics-accurate, so props to him. Doesn't make up for the Bible, though.
So there you go... coincidence or thievery? You decide. I should point out, in Bob's defense, he did also make these swell Seraphim and Saint of Killers Minimates, which I didn't do... but is he just trying to cover his tracks, Create plausible denyability? Dunno. I still can't figure out if he's this guy or not.